On July 20, 1957, the first service was held in a house, the only structure on the church’s property at the time. On February 13, 1958, Beautiful Savior was marked as an official mission congregation. On November 22, 1970, a new church building was dedicated. The construction of the new church building also led to the remodeling of the original church structure to a fellowship hall. In the years that followed, Beautiful Savior assisted in establishing Eternal Savior Lutheran Church. In 1979, the third phase of the 1970 remodel was finished as a 15 classroom education wing was constructed. In 1981, Beautiful Savior Lutheran School began, it occupied the education wing. Beautiful Savior assisted in the beginning of the mission church Risen Savior in 1986.

​

In 1991, 2 additional buildings were added to support the growth of the school. Beautiful Savior maintained steady and consistent membership and even growth in the church and school for much of the 20th century. In 2003, large scale construction was finished to add an entirely new education building for the grade school and ELC. Over the next nearly two decades, hundreds of children would grow up on the Beautiful Savior’s campus. Beautiful Savior has been blessed with many great pastors leading the church and school over the past sixty years.